Thursday, August 14, 2008

Book #24, Dimension of Miracles, Robert Sheckley

Finished this novel tonight (this is my second reading of it, the first being about eight years ago).
Took several thousand words of notes, which should come in handy for a new critical piece I'll be writing during the next two weeks.

2 comments:

Unknown said...

Alvaro,
You speak of writing a critical piece on Sheckley's book, which reminded me of a question I have for book commentators; is a review basically the same as a critique?
R.Z.

Alvaro Zinos-Amaro said...

I'm sure this is not the only answer, but it is one answer.

According to the "Penguin Dictionary of Literary Tems":

REVIEW - (a) A short notice or discussion or critical article in a paper, journal or periodical; (b) A journal or periodical containing articles on literature, art and philosophy. The Edinburgh Review at is a famous example: so is the Quarterly Review. Publications like Horizon, Scrutiny, the London Magazine, Essays in Criticism and Encounter
might well be placed in this category. See also Periodical.

CRITIQUE - A full-dress, detailed review and assessment of a literary work. The term may also denote a treatise (q.v.), such as Kant's Critique of Judgment (1790).

So the difference has to do with length and level of detail. Other discussions of these two terms seem to follow a similar line of thought, and may specify what that "detail" is.