Strange Horizons posted a 2009 Year-In-Review feature today, written by SH reviewers; it includes some of my comments on noteworthy items I encountered last year. Link-y:
Strange Horizons 2009 Year-In-Review Feature
In general there is some slight overlap in titles discussed by the various reviewers.
Interestingly, it looks like I'm the only one who recommended new 2009 short story collections by Jack Skillingstead and James van Pelt. That's a shame, considering the strength of their work.
For more on what people enjoyed in 2009 check out the epic five-part post over at SF Signal's Mind-Meld. (Jot down all the titles that overlap with SH recommendations and then immediately ignore those; if both reviewers AND writers/editors liked them, surely they have to be too "popular" to be any good. Just kidding.)